Home / Missions / Regulatory / Appealed Decisions

Administrative Appeals

There are times when decisions are appealed on the issuance or denial of a permit. The appeals received by the Mississippi Valley Division Headquarters are shown below.

For general information regarding the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Administrative Appeals process, you may contact Brian Oberlies, Mississippi Valley Division Regulatory Appeals Review Officer, at brian.m.oberlies@usace.army.mil or call (601) 634-5820.

 

MVD Table of Appeals 

District  Appellant  Processing #  Type of Appeal  Date Received  Date Completed  Decision  Final District Action
New Orleans Ted Hicks MVN-2020-00841 Jurisdictional Determination 7/19/2022   Not Accepted EPA Referral
New Orleans Scott D'Agostino MVN-2020-00844 Jurisdictional Determination 5/9/20200   Not Accepted N/A
New Orleans Grand Lake, LLC MVN-2020-00995 Jurisdictional Determination 1/3/2022     Pending
New Orleans Dearman Gray, LLC MVN-2020-01201 Jurisdictional Determination 11/1/2021     Pending
Rock Island Dan Cornelison MVR-2021-00208 Jurisdictional Determination 7/16/2021 5/3/2022 Has Merit Pending
New Orleans Garry Lewis -19 ac MVN-2020-00041-1 Jurisdictional Determination 3/8/2021     Pending
New Orleans Garry Lewis - 40 ac MVN-2015-01591-1 Jurisdictional Determination 2/22/2021     Pending
New Orleans Jean-Paul Robert MVN-2020-00600 Jurisdictional Determination 11/10/2020 3/4/2021   Withdrawn by Appellant
Memphis Cole Fields MVM-2019-00317 Jurisdictional Determination 10/13/2020 6/25/2021 Has Merit  
Rock Island Don Wiederin MVR-RD-W-2020-633 Jurisdictional Determination 1/22/2021 6/21/2021   Withdrawn by Appellant
New Orleans Charles Mitchell MVN-2011-00717 Permit Denial 6/17/2020     Pending
 Rock Island  Greg Poor  CEMVR-ODP-2018-0869  Jurisdictional
Determination		 11/19/2018 4/1/2019 Has Merit Documentation supplemented; JD reaffirmed
 Rock Island Timber Lane Farms 2017-00830  Jurisdictional Determination  1/22/2018 2/21/2018 Not Accepted N/A
 St. Paul  City of Delano  1999-08089-MLV   Jurisdictional Determination  11/7/2017  12/18/2017  Not accepted N/A
 New Orleans  Garry Lewis  2015-00321   Jurisdictional Determination  7/6/2017  8/18/17  Not accepted  N/A
 Rock Island Tim McCandless  2017-00625   Jurisdictional Determination  6/20/2017  3/6/2018 Has merit Documentation supplemented; JD reaffirmed
 St. Paul KAS Investments, LLC  2015-02665   Jurisdictional Determination  5/3/2017 4/2/2018 Has merit Documentation supplemented; JD reaffirmed
 Rock Island Warner Engineering  CEMVR-OD-P-2016-0398  Jurisdictional Determination  7/31/2017  8/31/2017  Withdrawn by Applicant  N/A
 New Orleans Garry Lewis  MVN-2015-01591-SK  Jurisdictional Determination  10/3/2016 9/1/2017   Has Merit Documentation supplemented; JD reaffirmed
Rock Island Wendling Quarries 2013-723 Jurisdictional Determination 4/15/2016  5/13/2016 Not accepted N/A
New Orleans John Carlson MVN-2014-02807 Jurisdictional Determination 4/4/2016 4/15/2016 Withdrawn by Applicant N/A 
Rock Island Jeffrey McCorkle 2015-608 Jurisdictional Determination 1/21/2016 2/1/2016 Withdrawn by Applicant  N/A
Rock Island Metro Sand and Gravel 2015-305 Jurisdictional Determination 10/26/2015  11/10/16 Has merit Reevaluated and modified JD
New Orleans Vincent Sotile MVN-2015-01284 Jurisdictional Determination 9/16/2015 10/13/2015 Not Accepted N/A 
Memphis Brad Caviness 2014-104 Jurisdictional Determination 7/21/2015  7/12/2016  Has merit Documentation supplemented; JD reaffirmed
New Orleans Scott Nesbit MVN-2014-02134 Jurisdictional Determination 3/9/2015 6/8/2015  Has Merit  Reevaluated and modified JD
Vicksburg Washington Parish Reservoir Commission MVK-2012-1240 Permit Denial 8/17/2015   7/15/2016  Has merit  Pending
St. Paul Vic Gunderson 2008-00520-LED  Jurisdictional Determination 7/14/2014  3/30/2015  Has Merit Documentation Supplemented; JD Reaffirmed 
Memphis Ed Avery MVM-2013-00283 Jurisdictional Determination  9/16/2014 3/2/2015  No Merit  n/a 
New Orleans Stacey Dominigue MVN-2014-01319 Jurisdictional Determination 7/24/2014 9/9/2014 No Merit n/a
Rock Island  Kentland Farms (Brian Wenzel) CEMVR-OD-P-2012-1619 Jurisdictional Determination  3/29/2013 9/30/13 Has Merit Documentation Supplemented:



JD Reaffirmed
St. Louis Swallow Tail, LLC.  MVS-2011-475 Jurisdictional Determination  8/15/2012 3/4/14 Has Merit Documentation Supplemented:



JD Reaffirmed
St. Louis  Brent McMinn MVS-2011-804 Jurisdictional Determination  8/13/2012 10/5/2012 Not Accepted n/a

New  Orleans

 Amanda Phillips MVN-2011-03181-SK Jurisdictional Determination  5/29/2012 11/1/2012 Has Merit Documentation supplemented; JD reaffirmed
New Orleans  N59 Ventures, LLC. (Michael Saucier) MVN-2011-1193-EQ Jurisdictional Determination  4/23/2012 6/1/2012 Withdrawn by Applicant n/a
St. Paul  Hawkes Peat Company, Inc. 2007-1914-DJS Jurisdictional Determination  4/6/2012 10/24/2012 Has Merit Documentation supplemented; JD reaffirmed
St. Louis  Limited Leasing Company MVS-2011-00177 Permit Denial  11/7/2011 7/8/13 No Merit Permit Decision Upheld
St. Louis  J.T.R. , Inc. MVS-2011-00178 Permit Denial  11/7/2011 7/8/13 No Merit Permit Decision Upheld
St. Louis  Captiol Sands Company, Inc. MVS-2008-00193 Permit Denial  11/7/2011 7/8/13 No Merit Permit Decision Upheld
New Orleans  Hebert Land (David Hebert)  MVN-2010-01775-SQ  Jurisdictional Determination  8/16/2011 6/10/13 Has Merit Documentation Supplemented:



JD Reaffirmed
New Orleans  Hebert Land (David Hebert)  MVN-2010-01775-SQ  Jurisdictional Determination  5/19/2011 5/25/2011 Withdrawn by Applicant n/a
New Orleans  Belle-Kent (John King, agent)  MVN-2010-01357-SY  Jurisdictional Determination  3/4/2011 7/26/2011 Has Merit Documentation Supplemented:



JD Reaffirmed
St. Paul  Hey and Associates (Reddelien)  2008-04314-DJP  Jurisdictional Determination  9/23/2010 10/21/2010 Not Accepted n/a
Rock Island  Hunt-Lima Drainage District  CEMVR-OD-P-2010-0171  Jurisdictional Determination  9/23/2010 10/13/2010 Not Accepted n/a
New Orleans  Gary Landrieu  MVN-2009-01686-SB-A  Jurisdictional Determination  7/26/2010 11/9/2010 Has Merit Documentation supplemented; JD reaffirmed
New Orleans  Gary Landrieu  MVN-2009-01686-SB-A  Jurisdictional Determination  6/14/2010 6/18/2010 Not Accepted n/a
New Orleans  Marvin Catrett  MVN-2010-00791-SA  Jurisdictional Determination  6/7/2010 6/14/2010 Not Accepted n/a
New Orleans  Norris Cheramie  MVN-2008-3214-EPP  Permit Denial  4/21/2010 4/29/2010 Not Accepted n/a
St. Paul  Mitch Michaelson  MVP-2009-02546-BLW  Jurisdictional Determination  1/6/2010 1/8/2010 Not Accepted n/a
New Orleans  Ms. Ginette Clement  MVN 2008-2486  Permit Denial  11/2/2009 11/2/2009 Not Accepted n/a
St. Paul  Brian Krakauer  2009-2168-RMG  Jurisdictional Determination  8/26/2009 10/27/2009 Withdrawn by Applicant n/a
St. Paul  Chuck Bye  2005-7407-CKK (2009-05440)  Jurisdictional Determination  8/7/2009 9/24/2009 Withdrawn by Applicant New info submitted; appellant applied for permit; MVP denied without prejudice (401)
Rock Island  D Construction  CEMVR-OD-P-2009-0497  Jurisdictional Determination  7/16/2009 11/6/2009 No Merit n/a
St. Paul  Robert Perry  2008-1245-ADB  Jurisdictional Determination  8/22/2008 10/2/2008 Not Accepted n/a
New Orleans  RJM Enterprises, Inc.  MVN 2007-02846-SQ  Jurisdictional Determination  8/7/2008 9/22/2009 Has Merit Documentation supplemented; JD reaffirmed
St. Paul  Falls Memorial Hospital  2007-5740-KJU  Jurisdictional Determination  8/7/2008 5/8/2009 No Merit n/a
New Orleans  Fashion Plantation Estates LLC  MVN-2004-3150-EGG  Permit Denial  6/23/2008 7/15/2009 Has Merit Supplemented documentation; decision reaffirmed
New Orleans  Mr. Edmond Rivet  2007-03437-SQ  Jurisdictional Determination  6/19/2008 7/3/2008 Not Accepted n/a
St. Paul  Mr. David Abraham  2004-04040-EMN  Permit Denial  4/7/2008 5/8/2009 Has Merit Documentation amended; decison reaffirmed
New Orleans  Moesa LLC (James Morrison)  MVN-2007-04563-SG  Jurisdictional Determination  3/10/2008 12/15/2008 Has Merit Supplemented documentation; JD reaffirmed
New Orleans  Mr. Wallace Carline  MVN 2007-03138-SH  Jurisdictional Determination  3/5/2008 5/2/2008 Not Accepted n/a
New Orleans  Mr. Wallace Carline  MVN 2007-03138-SH  Jurisdictional Determination  1/4/2008 2/4/2008 Not Accepted n/a
New Orleans  Mr. Roland Bailey  MVN-2005-2099-WW  Proffered Permit  12/18/2007 11/16/2008 Has Merit Proffered permit revised; permit issued
New Orleans  Mr. Steve Buratt  MVN-2005-366-CZ  Permit Denial  11/23/2007 12/18/2007 Not Accepted n/a
St. Louis  Mr. Mitch Parris  2007-520  Jurisdictional Determination  10/29/2007 5/15/2008 Has Merit Supplemented documentation; JD reaffirmed
St. Paul  Ms. Karen Malonis  2006-4018-DJP  Jurisdictional Determination  10/19/2007 8/9/2008 No Merit n/a
St. Paul  Mr. Ned Dikmen  2006-4013-DJP  Jurisdictional Determination  10/19/2007 8/9/2008 No Merit n/a
New Orleans  Mr. Paul Hogan  MVN-2005-4113-SZ  Jurisdictional Determination  9/26/2007 2/13/2008 Has Merit Supplemented documentation; JD reaffirmed
Rock Island  Todd & Vicki Ekern  P2007-615  Issued Permit  8/28/2007 9/26/2007 Not Accepted n/a
St. Paul  Ms. Karen Malonis  2006-4018-DJP  Jurisdictional Determination  8/20/2007 9/21/2007 Not Accepted n/a
St. Paul  Mr. Ned Dikmen  2006-4013-DJP  Jurisdictional Determination  8/20/2007 9/21/2007 Not Accepted n/a
St. Paul  Mr. Ron Sierra  2006-1997-DJP  Jurisdictional Determination  4/25/2007 8/10/2007 No Merit n/a
New Orleans  Fashion Plantation (Lakeside Church)  MVN-2004-3150-EGG  Permit Denial  8/15/2006 9/13/2006 Not Accepted n/a
New Orleans  John Neal  MVN-2004-3497-CZ  Proffered Permit  6/27/2006 7/19/2006 No Merit n/a
New Orleans  Frank Galaforo  2006-488-SU  Jurisdictional Determination  5/18/2006 6/19/2006 Withdrawn by Applicant n/a
Memphis  Mr. Mike Skelton  MVM-2004-290  Jurisdictional Determination  11/25/2005 2/23/2006 No Merit but Remanded for better documentation After reconsideration of JD, determined that no permit was required.
Memphis  Mr. Marty Bennett  2005-543-RW  Jurisdictional Determination  10/18/2005 1/11/2006 No Merit Jurisdictional Determination upheld
St. Louis  Mr. & Mrs. Ritter  2005-05140  Jurisdictional Determination  9/13/2005 9/29/2005 Not Accepted n/a
Memphis  Mr. John Stephens  2005-406  Jurisdictional Determination  7/11/2005 10/27/2005 No Merit Jurisdictional Determination upheld
New Orleans  Ms Elvira Steppes  2005-151  Jurisdictional Determination  6/1/2005 7/6/2005 Withdrawn by Applicant n/a
New Orleans  Babin  MVN-2004-4421-SU  Jurisdictional Determination  1/6/2005 1/6/2005 Withdrawn by Applicant n/a
New Orleans  Naylon  EKK-20-030-3672  Denial  1/5/2005 4/15/2005 No Merit Denial decision upheld
St. Louis  Havener  2004-00420  Jurisdictionalal Determination  9/30/2004 12/6/2004 No Merit Jurisdictionalal Determination upheld
New Orleans  LCNI  MVN-2004-3349-SC  Jurisdictionalal Determination  9/8/2004 11/29/2004 No Merit JD Decision Upheld
New Orleans  Mr. Phillip Caballero  WN-20-020-1156-2  Proffered Permit  7/20/2004 10/25/2004 No Merit Permit Decision Upheld
St. Paul  Dan & John Zander  03-07976-DAS  Issued Permit  7/12/2004 8/2/2004 Not Accepted n/a
Vicksburg  Kitterlin  200310580 Jurisdictionalal Determination  4/7/2004 8/21/2004 Has Merit Supplemented documentation, upheld Jurisdictionalal determination
Memphis  John Conner  200300385 Permit Denial  3/3/2004 9/1/2004 No Merit Permit Denial Upheld
Rock Island  Larry Gauer  441180-1  Jurisdictional Determination  11/10/2003 3/4/2004 Has Merit Revised JD - did not pursue regulatory Jurisdictional
Memphis  John Conner  200200758 Jurisdictional Determination  10/10/2003 6/8/2004 Has Merit Supplemented documentation, upheld Jurisdictional
New Orleans  James Gilmore  20-030-3769  Jurisdictional Determination  9/15/2003 2/10/2004 No Merit Jurisdictional Determination Upheld
New Orleans  Lisa Thiel  EZ-20-020-1355  Denial  7/7/2003 6/18/2004 Has Merit Denial Decision Upheld
New Orleans  Reeves  WX-20-020-2078-0  Proffered Permit  5/5/2003 12/16/2003 Has Merit Supplemented Documentation Upheld Permit Decision - 10/19/04
Vicksburg  William Roach  200213210 Jurisdictional Determination  3/18/2003 3/28/2003 Withdrawn by Applicant n/a
New Orleans  Mr. William Guste  20-020-3668  Jurisdictional Determination  1/30/2003 8/27/2003 No Merit Jurisdictional Determination upheld
New Orleans  Judson Baptist Church  20-030-1550  Jurisdictional Determination  1/27/2003 8/11/2003 Not Accepted N/A
Memphis  Mobley Construction  1999461110 Proffered Permit  1/21/2003 8/27/2003 No Merit Proffered Permit upheld, Applicant provided additional information for district’s consideration
New Orleans  Tammany Holding Corporation  20-020-1717  Jurisdictional Determination  11/15/2002 3/6/2003 Has Merit Supplemented documentation, upheld Jurisdictional. Permit issued.
New Orleans  Mr. Joffery Easley  20-020-3030  Jurisdictional Determination  10/2/2002 2/11/2003 No Merit Jurisdictional Determination Upheld
New Orleans  Mr. Phillip Caballero  WN-20-1156-0  Proffered Permit  9/9/2002 12/11/2002 Withdrawn by Applicant n/a
New Orleans  W. Calcasieu Port Harbor, & Terminal Permit District  WG-19-980-2004  Proffered Permit  8/22/2002 5/16/2003 No Merit Permit Issued
New Orleans  Mr. Ricky Bourg  EL-19-990-3578ES-19-970-5668  Permit Denial  4/3/2002 10/2/2002 Has Merit Permit Issued for Modified Project
Vicksburg  Memphis Stone & Gravel Company  200113910 Jurisdictional Determination  3/31/2002 7/22/2002 Has Merit Revised JD
St. Paul  Mr. Richard Kesler  200104152 Jurisdictional Determination  10/10/2001 7/16/2002 Has Merit Revised Documentation Determination to support JD
New Orleans  Mr. Fennon Rogers & Mr. John Beach  EG-19-990-3786  Permit Denial  7/31/2001 8/16/2002 Has Merit District supplemented record, permit application withdrawn by District due to non response by applicant.
New Orleans  Mr. Keith Talbot & Ms. Jane Hood  WM-20-000-0997  Permit Denial  6/27/2001 7/26/2002 Has Merit  Supplemented Documentation Upheld Permit Denial - 10/16/02
New Orleans  Mr. Ricky Bourg  EL-19-990-3578 & ES-19-970-5668  Permit Denial  5/30/2001 10/23/2001 Withdrawn by Applicant N/A
Memphis  Mobley Construction Company  White R.99-111  Proffered Permit  3/23/2001 6/1/2001*  Withdrawn by Applicant N/A
New Orleans  Mr. Eldridge Daniel  20-000-0562  Jurisdictional Determination  3/22/2001 6/21/2001 Has Merit District supplemented JD Documentation
New Orleans  Capt.  George Maynard  20-000-3496  Jurisdictional Determination  9/14/2000 12/20/2000 No Merit Jurisdictional determination upheld
New Orleans  Port W. St. Mary  20-000-2689  Jurisdictional Determination  8/24/2000 11/21/2000 No Merit Jurisdictional determination upheld
New Orleans  Mr. Alan Simmons  20-000-2532  Jurisdictional Determination  8/14/2000 9/11/2000 Not Accepted n/a
New Orleans  Mr. S. E. Yandle  EI-19-980-0243  Permit Denial  7/26/2000 11/6/2000 No Merit Permit was denied
New Orleans  Lonesome Development  EG-19-980-0934-1  Permit Denial  6/29/2000 10/13/2000 Has Merit Supplemented Documentation Modified Permit issued 5/29/02
St. Paul  City of Richfield  99-04552-JJY  Proffered Permit  6/5/2000 8/30/2000 Has Merit Pending
Memphis  Mrs. Martha Manley  00062-0070  Jurisdictional Determination  5/3/2000 5/31/2000 Not Accepted n/a
New Orleans  Mr. Gary Gambel  EE-19-970-3239  Proffered Permit  4/4/2000 6/30/2000 No Merit re-offered permit- 7/18/00  issued -  9/11/00
New Orleans  Mr. Herman Wayne Sharp  EB-19-970-1093  Permit Denial  6/10/1999 7/31/2000 Has Merit